Ewe 2: A case study

Teacher ToolboxResourcesTimelineOur TeamGuest book

So you what to give Ewe 2 a whirl with your students? Just contact Keith Nuthall and he will get you started.

Tutorial CaseCloning CaseContent Standards

Welcome educators. Ewe 2 is an inquiry-oriented activity that places students in the position to ask great questions, seek out the answers, develop new relationships, and take a stand on a current hot issue: cloning. Ewe 2: A case study

The project utilizes a "case study" approach.  If University Law and Medical schools think case studies are a great idea, why not apply the concept to K-12 education? Students will be exploring the scientific and ethical impacts of cloning on individuals and society. A "case" or story is used to frame the many issues and perspectives involved in both partial and whole body cloning of humans. Students are asked to both create an action plan, and develop a set of possible consequences.  More importantly, they will learn a new way to approach a complex issue.  As stated in the student introduction, Bob Marley once said, "None but ourselves can free our minds."

Here is a quick run down of Ewe 2.

The Tutorial: A Meating of Minds.

Students may need a warm up. Case studies are new to many students. Students tend to want to jump directly to the consequences without thoroughly exploring the issues and perspectives.  In addition, this project utilizes lots of technology toys, and it may be useful to let them experiment with the tools before sinking their teeth into a "meatier" case.

The Case: Exploring the Undiscovered Country

What will Gerrard do?  What are Dr. Osgood's motives, and what is with that  "old man?"  Exploring the Undiscovered Country was carefully crafted to place student in the middle of the cloning controversy. Students are required to identify issues and perspectives, validate resources, develop an action plan, and analyze their choices.

The Resources

The technology tools in Ewe 2 were developed to help students scaffold their thinking by tapping  prior knowledge, building new relationships, and by sharing their beliefs with a larger audience.

IP based videoconferencing: CU-SeeMe tools have been incorporated to facilitate strong student-to-student relationships.  More details.

Download the cases: [ MS Word | PDF ]

On-Line surveys: Lets test the waters.  Just how do students feel about cloning, and what is the relationship between the students and adult community?

Survey Name: Cloning Student Pre-Survey
Password: ewe2

Survey Name: Community Cloning Survey
Password: ewe2

Survey Name: Cloning Student Post- Survey
Password: ewe2

On-line discussion board: The discussion board was built as a place to "hang" your ideas for feedback.  More details

On-line forums: These forms were developed to help students "think through" their beliefs.

Grading Rubrics: How will the student's writing be evaluated?  Here are two example rubrics that will help guide your students.

Timeline

Ewe 2, like most inquiry-based activities, requires a highly structured learning environment expertly crafted by the individual classroom teacher.  Structured inquiry?  All too often, student-centered learning activities are coupled with the phrase "guide-on-the-side."  Note: Being a guide-on-the-side is hard work.   So what about the timeline?

Your curriculum responsibilities, access to technology and group of students will have a tremendous effect on the timeline.  The project has been constructed to allow for multiple entry points.

  • Maybe you will skip the tutorial case and dive right into the cloning case.  
  • You may download the "cases" and use them as a single day activity.  [ MS Word | PDF ]
  • You might stretch the unit to weave throughout an entire semester.
  • You might not use the videoconferencing activities, or discussion board.

Each teacher needs to evaluate their own learning environment, and adjust the project to meet their needs. 

Our pilot group will be tackling the entire project, and we intend to run the project for three weeks.  Keeping in mind:

"Things take longer than they do."

Design Team

Our project began as one of four California Technology Assistance Program grants sponsored by the San Diego County Office of Education.  Pacbell jumped on board to provide financial support for IP videoconferencing infrastructure.  Thank you to these organizations for allowing our team to take a risk.  We would enjoy hearing from you. Please sign our guest book.

Lead Mentor: Keith Nuthall, Instructional Technology Specialist, Poway Unified School District.

Support Mentor: Tom March, ozline.com

Support Mentor: Ian Campbell, Biology Teacher, Poway Unified School District.

Support Mentor: Brooks Park, Biology Teacher, Grossmont Unified School District.

Support Teacher: Isla Cordela, Biology Teacher, San Dieguito Union High School District

 

 

Ewe 2: A Case Study
launched March '99, last updated March '99
copyright © 1999
all rights reserved

Sponsors:
San Diego County Office Of Education
California Technology Assistance Program
Pacific Bell
Contact Information